Brady Center: Doctors to Appeal Docs v. Glocks Decision

Brady Center: Doctors to Appeal Docs v. Glocks Decision


FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE July 28, 2014 Jennifer Fuson 202-370-8128 jfuson@bradymail.org                                                        

Washington, D.C. – Florida doctors represented by the Brady Center to Prevent Gun Violence and the Ropes & Gray law firm will appeal a 2-1 decision by the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that ruled forbidding doctors from talking to their patients about guns was constitutional. The doctors will seek an en banc review from the full 11th Circuit.

Wollschlaeger v. Scott, commonly known as Docs v. Glocks, is a challenge to a 2011 Florida law that restricts doctors from advising patients about the risks of guns. Organizations representing 11,000 state health providers, including the Florida chapters of the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Academy of Family Physicians, had challenged the law as violating doctors’ and patients’ First Amendment right to free speech. Lawyers with Ropes & Gray, the Brady Center and Astigarraga Davis brought the lawsuit and are representing the doctors.

“If the appellate court’s decision is allowed to stand, the corporate gun lobby and its political cronies will be given license to silence the medical community from speaking the truth to patients about the real risks of guns in the home, and any powerful industry will be able to dictate whether families get complete, honest information about the dangers posed by its products,” said Jonathan Lowy, Director, Legal Action Project, Brady Center to Prevent Gun Violence.

“Florida’s gag rule will place our children at risk. The First Amendment does not allow the gun lobby to decide what doctors can tell patients. We are seeking review of this unjust decision by the entire court, and we hope and fully expect that it will be reversed,” added Lowy.

In a lengthy dissent, U.S. Circuit Judge Charles Wilson agreed that the law was an infringement on the First Amendment rights of doctors. “The act prohibits or significantly chills doctors from expressing their views and providing information to patients about one topic, and one topic only, firearms. Regardless of whether we agreed with the message conveyed by doctors to patients about firearms, I think it is perfectly clear that doctors have a First Amendment right to convey that message,” reads Wilson’s dissent.

Gun Deaths Outpace Motor Vehicle Deaths in 14 States and DC in 2011

Recent Press Release from the Violence Policy Center.  You may want to visit their website here for other interesting gun violence violence prevention reports.


For Release:
Tuesday, July 15, 2014
Contacts:
Avery Palmer Violence Policy Center (202) 822-8200 x104
Sue Hornik States United to Prevent Gun Violence (631) 275-8986

Gun Deaths Outpace Motor Vehicle Deaths in 14 States and the District of Columbia in 2011

To reduce gun death and injury, firearms should be subject to federal health and safety standards just like all other consumer products

Washington, DC — Gun deaths outpaced motor vehicle deaths in 14 states and the District of Columbia in 2011, the most recent year for which comprehensive nationwide data is available, a new analysis from the Violence Policy Center (VPC) finds.

In 2011, there were more gun deaths than motor vehicle deaths in the following states: Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Illinois, Louisiana, Maryland, Michigan, Nevada, Ohio, Oregon, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, and Washington State, as well as the District of Columbia (see below for the mortality figures for each jurisdiction). Data is from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s National Center for Injury Prevention and Control and is the most recent available to compare death rates from both products.

This is the third year the VPC has issued its annual report comparing gun deaths to motor vehicle deaths by state. Gun deaths include gun suicides, homicides, and fatal unintentional shootings; motor vehicle deaths include both occupants and pedestrians.

More than 90 percent of American households own a car while little more than a third of American households have a gun. Americans’ exposure to motor vehicles vastly outweighs their exposure to firearms. Yet in 2011, there were 32,351 gun deaths and 35,543 motor vehicle deaths nationwide. In 1999, there were 28,874 gun deaths and 42,624 motor vehicle deaths nationwide.

Firearms are the only consumer product in America not regulated by the federal government for health and safety. Meanwhile, motor vehicle deaths are on a steady decline, thanks to decades of public health-based injury prevention strategies and proven consumer product safety regulation standards designed to reduce death and injury.

“Gun violence is a public health crisis with an unacceptable toll on human life,” states VPC Legislative Director Kristen Rand. “To reduce gun death and injury, firearms must be regulated for health and safety just as we regulate motor vehicles and all other consumer products.”

“We didn’t put up with a free-for-all on our highways, and it’s time to end the gun violence free-for-all in our schools and neighborhoods,” states Sue Hornik, executive director of States United to Prevent Gun Violence.

The report includes specific recommendations on how the federal government should regulate firearms to reduce gun death and injury. To read the full report, please visit http://www.vpc.org/studies/gunsvscars14.pdf.

Here are the figures for each of the 14 states and the District of Columbia: Alaska: 126 gun deaths, 87 motor vehicle deaths

Arizona: 964 gun deaths, 872 motor vehicle deaths
Colorado: 573 gun deaths, 512 motor vehicle deaths
District of Columbia: 86 gun deaths, 39 motor vehicle deaths
Illinois: 1,114 gun deaths, 1,080 motor vehicle deaths
Louisiana: 865 gun deaths, 750 motor vehicle deaths
Maryland: 542 gun deaths, 517 motor vehicle deaths
Michigan: 1,156 gun deaths, 1,016 motor vehicle deaths
Nevada: 376 gun deaths, 281 motor vehicle deaths
Ohio: 1,227 gun deaths, 1,178 motor vehicle deaths
Oregon: 420 gun deaths, 371 motor vehicle deaths
Utah: 308 gun deaths, 277 motor vehicle deaths
Vermont: 78 gun deaths, 62 motor vehicle deaths
Virginia: 868 gun deaths, 816 motor vehicle deaths
Washington: 624 gun deaths, 554 motor vehicle deaths




About the Violence Policy Center:  The Violence Policy Center is a national educational organization working to stop gun death and injury. Follow the VPC on Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube.

States United to Prevent Gun Violence (www.CeasefireUSA.org) is a national non-profit organization working to support state-based gun violence prevention groups and help build new state-led organizations. States United believes that all Americans deserve to live in a country free from the fear, threat, and devastation caused by gun violence.